Can Holbrook’s Attack Overcome Newcastle’s Light Forward Pack?

Newcastle Knights Head Coach: Justin Holbrook (Photo: Newcastle Herald)

The Newcastle Knights enter the 2026 season at a crossroads. After years of inconsistency and lack of attacking spark, the club could finally turn a corner, but how that plays out will decide the year.

The attack looks stronger than it has in a while, and for the first time in years, the team seems to have a consistent spine. Justin Holbrook’s arrival, a coach who backs attacking football and structured ball movement, signals a clear shift from the stagnation that has frustrated fans. On paper, this side looks capable of more than it has shown in recent seasons.

Still, balance is a concern. Newcastle’s best games have usually been built on defence. Strong line speed, physicality, and scramble defence have often been the difference. That kind of effort has always reflected the club and the town.

Brett White has joined the Knights as defensive coach. He has a proven record and has worked under some of the game’s best coaches. His job is to keep the team tough and organised at the back while the attack improves.

Leo Thompson is one of the best young props in the NRL, making metres and taking tough carries every game. Adam Elliott’s departure adds to the concern. Without them, Newcastle looks light up front, which could be a problem against the top sides. Jacob Saifiti and Brodie Jones will need to take on more of the load, while Mat Croker and Dylan Lucas will have to step up when called on.

Knights Captain and Star Fullback Kalyn Ponga (Photo: The Chronicle)

Much of Newcastle’s season will depend on Kalyn Ponga. Injuries and past concussion issues are the biggest risk. A fit Ponga could have a Dally M level season playing alongside Dylan Brown at five-eighth, Fletcher Sharpe at halfback, and Sandon Smith at dummy half. All three are strong running threats, which should open up space for Ponga to make an impact. At the other end, injuries could limit him or end his career, with Sharpe ready to take on more responsibility if needed.

A full-season return for Dom Young will be crucial. Having played alongside Sandon Smith at the Roosters and picking up valuable experience there, he should be in line to score even more tries than before he left. His height also gives him an edge, particularly on kicks.

Knights' New Signing Dylan Brown (Photo: Fox Sports)

I see the Knights starting the season strongly and they could easily be preseason favourites. But they could also get found out halfway through the year. How they respond after losses and when things aren’t working will be key. Holbrook needs to find the side he wants early and stick with it, particularly at 7, to give the spine consistency.

Keeping local players in the team is still important. The squad includes homegrown talents like Bradman Best, Mat Croker, Fletcher Sharpe, Lachlan Crouch, Phoenix Crossland, Brodie Jones, Dylan Lucas, Jermaine McEwen, Jacob Saifiti, and Pasami Saulo. These players, along with many young juniors coming through the pathways, show the strength of Newcastle’s development system and keep the club connected to the town and its supporters.

Knights Forward Mat Croker (Photo: Newcastle Herald)

The Knights enter 2026 with potential and excitement around their attack and spine. How the forwards step up and key players stay on the field will ultimately shape their season.

My prediction is the Knights will finish around 10th and miss the finals.